Khamis, 6 Oktober 2011

Malaysia Today - Your Source of Independent News

0 ulasan
Klik GAMBAR Dibawah Untuk Lebih Info
Sumber Asal Berita :-

Malaysia Today - Your Source of Independent News


WIKILEAKS: IRAN BLOCKED, AGAIN, FROM MALAYSIA ARMS SHOW

Posted: 06 Oct 2011 01:00 AM PDT

The Ambassador sent a message to the Prime Minister alerting him to the impending U.S. withdrawal. Within 90 minutes, Defense Ministry Secretary General Abubakar informed DATT that Malaysia had rescinded its approval for the Iranian exhibit because Iran had "broken its promise" by displaying unauthorized items. Foreign Minister Rais Yatim, acting on instruction from the Prime Minister, telephoned the Ambassador and confirmed the same decision and rationale. Rais Yatim stood by the Foreign Ministry's position that Iran's participation in DSA (exhibiting certain non-lethal gear and apparently small arms as negotiated with the Iranians) would not violate UNSCRs.

THE CORRIDORS OF POWER

Raja Petra Kamarudin

Classified By: Political Section Chief Mark D. Clark for reasons 1.4 (b and d).

Summary

1.  (C) Malaysia on April 22 blocked Iran from participating in the Defense Services Asia (DSA) military sales exhibition. This followed a week of decisions in favor of Iran and reversals, and continuous interventions by the Embassy and our UK and French counterparts.  The Malaysians reached a compromise withIran on April 19 and again on April 21, allowing Iran to display certain small arms and defensive gear (still in violation of UNSCRs). 

The Ambassador called Prime Minister Abdullah on April 21 and alerted him to the situation.  On the morning of April 22, Iran violated its agreement with Malaysia by preparing a display that included rockets and artillery shells, prompting the Defense Ministry to order a halt to Iran's participation.  The Foreign Minister confirmed this decision in a call to the Ambassador, but did not concede that Iran's participation in DSA would constitute a violation of UNSCRs. 

Another serious concern pertains to the import from Iran into Malaysia of various arms and arms related items, a clear violation of UNSCR 1747 regardless of the exhibition.  We believe these concerns may be usefully addressed by P3 or UN sanctions committee discussions with the Malaysian mission in New York.  Our forceful response to the DSA incident should help us as we pursue other nonproliferation concerns with Malaysia.  End Summary.

Weekend Back and Forth

2.  (C) Embassy engagement, including by the Ambassador and DATT, continued through the April 19-20 weekend following the preceding four days of diplomatic interventions (reftels) aimed at convincing Malaysia to rescind its permission to allow Iranian participation in the DSA.  After several GOM decisions to stop Iran and subsequent reversals in Iran's favor, Embassy DATT received assurances from the Defense Ministry ahead of the April 20 kick-off ceremony that Iran would not be allowed to formally participate in DSA.

Throughout our discussions, the Defense Ministry referred to the Foreign Ministry's support for Iran and the Foreign Ministry's interpretation of UNSCRs as allowing Iran to join the DSA military sales exhibition.

Iran Regains Permission

3.  (C) On April 21, the first day of the public exhibition, we learned that the Defense Ministry had given the Iranian entities permission to open their booth.  This followed a meeting between the Iranian ambassador and Defense Ministry Secretary General Abubakar.  Defense Ministry officials and DSA representatives informed us that Iran would display small arms and non-lethal gear (a compromise discussed by Iran and Malaysia on April 19).  Contractors reconstructed the Iranian booth on the evening of April 21.

Ambassador Phones Prime Minister

4.  (C) The Ambassador phoned Prime Minister Abdullah Badawi late on April 21 after a hastily scheduled meeting with Deputy Prime Minister/Defense Minister Najib Tun Razak did not materialize (Najib delegated the meeting to his Secretary General).  The Ambassador alerted the Prime Minister to the DSA situation, and explained that we may be forced to withdraw official U.S. participation out of respect for the UNSC sanctions and not as an effort to embarrass Malaysia. The Prime Minister said he was unaware of the situation and would speak with Defense Minister Najib.

Rockets and Artillery Rounds - Iranians Go Too Far

5.  (C) On the morning of April 22, the Iranian exhibit appeared ready to open with a wide-ranging display that included 155mm and 125mm artillery rounds; various surface-to-surface and anti-tank rockets, and armor piercing rounds; surveillance gear, including night vision devices; protective gear for nuclear, biological, chemical threats (MOPP suit); models of naval vessels; and advertisements for aircraft parts.  (Note: We have forwarded a more detailed inventory to EAP/MTS and ISN.  End Note.)  DATT drew Defense Ministry officials' attention to this extensive display and informed them that on instruction from Washington we would withdraw official U.S. participation, including U.S. military exhibits, immediately upon the opening of the Iranian exhibit.  The Ambassador sent a message to the Prime Minister alerting him to the impending U.S. withdrawal.

6.  (C) Within 90 minutes, Defense Ministry Secretary General Abubakar informed DATT that Malaysia had rescinded its approval for the Iranian exhibit because Iran had "broken its promise" by displaying unauthorized items.  Foreign Minister Rais Yatim, acting on instruction from the Prime Minister, telephoned the Ambassador and confirmed the same decision and rationale.  Rais Yatim stood by the Foreign Ministry's position that Iran's participation in DSA (exhibiting certain non-lethal gear and apparently small arms as negotiated with the Iranians) would not violate UNSCRs.

7.  (C) UK officials informed us of their meeting later on April 22 with Secretary General Abubakar in which he said Malaysia had been "hurt and offended" that a "friendly nation" (Iran) had taken advantage of Malaysia's hospitality.

Abubakar described Iran's exhibit of large ordinance as a "clear breach" of UN sanctions.  It remained unclear how and on what basis Malaysia drew the line between acceptable and unacceptable military items for DSA display.

8.  (C) U.S., UK and French missions coordinated and shared information throughout the dispute over Iranian participation at DSA.  We also kept the Australian mission informed, while the UK and France worked to include Germany.

Comment

9.  (C) While aggressive diplomatic intervention by the U.S. and its allies has stopped Iran's participation the DSA arms show (at least as of this hour - DSA will continue for another two days), we recognize at least two serious concerns that should be addressed with Malaysia.  First, Malaysia does not agree with the P3 interpretation of UN sanctions against Iran, particularly paragraph 5 of UNSCR 1747, which would prohibit Iran's participation in a defense sales and marketing event and prohibit Iran's marketing of small arms and non-lethal military gear.  (Beyond Malaysia's own position, greater UNSC or P3 clarity on this issue and advance work with scheduled defense exhibitions may help to prevent similar situations from arising at the last minute; we note that Malaysia appeared unaware of the 2007 Brazil precedent prior to our demarche.)

10.  (C) Second, Iran's transfer to Malaysian territory of various arms and arms-related materiel for this exhibition appears to be a clear violation of UNSCR 1747.  This transfer, however, apparently has not met with any Malaysian government restrictions or concerns, outside of the question of what would be on public display at DSA.

11.  (C) We believe that a P3 or 1747 sanctions committee approach to Malaysia's UN mission, addressing the DSA incident and Iranian transfer of arms and arms-related materiel, represents a useful way to proceed.  Such an approach could clarify authoritative interpretations of UNSCRs, and reinforce the international community's serious concern over respect for UN sanctions on Iran.  A P3 or sanctions committee approach in New York would provide a good basis for follow-on discussions with the Foreign Ministry and GOM senior officials in Kuala Lumpur.

12.  (C) As a silver lining, the painful DSA incident has signaled clearly to the Prime Minister, the Defense Minister and the Foreign Minister that we view UN sanctions on Iran, related to Iran's non-compliance with UNSC demands regarding its nuclear program, as a very serious matter.  This should help us as we pursue other nonproliferation concerns with Malaysia.

KEITH (April 2008)

 

Kredit: www.malaysia-today.net

Malaysia Today - Your Source of Independent News

0 ulasan
Klik GAMBAR Dibawah Untuk Lebih Info
Sumber Asal Berita :-

Malaysia Today - Your Source of Independent News


The Fire Next Time

Posted: 05 Oct 2011 10:03 AM PDT

By Andrew Marshall, TIME

Whom do you call if you want to speak to Southeast Asia? Apply Henry Kissinger's famous question about Europe to the 11 countries that arc from the Himalayas to the Pacific, and an answer is equally elusive. Their economies, cultures and politics differ so dramatically that generalizing about Southeast Asia is a risky business.

But let's do it anyway. Southeast Asians have at least two things in common. First, they all know what it's like to live under authoritarian regimes and rulers. The latter range from brutal autocrats (Burma's recently retired General Than Shwe) to self-styled strongmen (Cambodia's Hun Sen) to leaders who benefit from repressive laws that safeguard the predominance of a single party (Malaysia's Najib Razak).

Second, Southeast Asians are bone weary of authoritarianism, and increasingly unafraid to say so. There is a growing demand for accountability and good governance that the region's elites and demidespots ignore at their peril. To call it a Southeast Asian Spring is an exaggeration. But the movement is youthful and social-media-savvy, and could precipitate changes just as profound as those in the Middle East.(See pictures of battles for Burmese democracy.)

Prime Minister Najib, who casts himself as a moderate, seems to realize this. His party, the United Malays National Organization, leads the National Front coalition, whose decades-old grip on power has sparked protests for electoral reform. In July police violently dispersed what should have been a peaceful rally by some 50,000 members of Bersih 2.0, a group campaigning for free and fair elections. (Bersihmeans clean.) Protesters used Twitter and YouTube to organize the rally and, later, undermine claims that the police acted with restraint.

On Sept. 15, his reformist credentials in shreds, Najib promised to scrap the Internal Security Act (ISA), which allows police to detain suspects indefinitely, along with the much abused Emergency Ordinance. He also vowed to loosen media restrictions and review the laws on freedom of assembly. It's hard to know whether he will keep his promises. But emboldened Malaysians will hold him to them, either at the polls — an election must be held by 2013 — or on the streets.

Najib's announcement provoked a swift defense of the ISA from neighboring Singapore, which also inherited the law from its British colonial days. The ISA is used "sparingly" to arrest terrorism suspects, and nobody has ever been detained only for their political beliefs, said the Singaporean government. That such a defense was felt necessary is telling. In a May election, opposition candidates — who want the ISA scrapped — made historic gains against the People's Action Party, which has ruled Singapore for half a century. The government retains "broad powers to limit citizens' rights and handicap political opposition," said the U.S. State Department in April.(See pictures of Malaysia.)

Indonesians haven't marched in huge numbers since toppling the dictator Suharto in 1998. But popular yearning for good governance could easily fill the streets again. President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono's approval rating is plummeting, thanks to corruption scandals implicating senior officials, and an upcoming Cabinet reshuffle will do little to halt it. Indonesia's strong economy won't stave off protests either. Stability requires functioning institutions, free media and an unfettered civil society, as well as economic growth.

Thailand is a case in point. It is now an "upper-middle income economy," with a gross national income per capita of $4,210, according to the World Bank. But it has been free-falling on other indexes, particularly those measuring corruption and media freedom, since the military overthrew yet another government in 2006. The street protests that followed were divisive and sometimes violent. But they encouraged millions of Thais to demand more say in decisions that affect their lives. Thai politicians, with their old-school reliance on patronage and payola, seem destined to fail them.

That goes double for the young. About a fifth of Southeast Asians are ages 15 to 24. Their youthful energy has so far been channeled into dynamic economies — but that doesn't mean the kids are all right, if statistics on unwanted pregnancies and drug use among Thai teenagers are anything to go by. And governments, institutions and firms across Southeast Asia still retain hierarchical structures that stifle youth and innovation.

This is especially true in Burma, where young people are key to reform: they have dominated every street protest since the military seized power in 1962. A nominally civilian government took office in March and has embarked upon reforms, suggesting that even Burma's hard-liners sense history is against them. In a recent interview, democracy icon Aung San Suu Kyi ruled out an Arab-style revolt, and not just because violence appalls her. With Southeast Asians finding their voices, inspiration could lie much closer to home.


Battle for Kelantan: Umno is optimistic

Posted: 04 Oct 2011 07:22 PM PDT

PAS has ruled the state since 1990 and another general election is around the corner. This time around, Umno is confident of dealing a blow, if not capturing the entire state.

The state government had alleged factions, one led by state PAS deputy commissioner III Nik Amar Nik Abdullah and deputy mentri besar Ahmad Yakcop as well as state PAS strongman Takiyuddin Hassan. The other, or rather operating in isolation, was PAS vice-president and state economic czar Husam Musa, whom many in Umno believe, is the political god-son of Nik Aziz.

Hawkeye, Free Malaysia Today

Kelantan Umno is optimistic of performing well in the impending general election because they claim that the PAS-led state government has lost its way due to stale policies and a lack of innovation to spur economic growth.

This gave rise to the possibility of Umno denying a two-thirds majority in the 45-member state legislative assembly while some of its leaders even forecasted a possible takeover of Kelantan.

Many Kelantan Umno leaders believe that Menteri Besar Nik Abdul Aziz Nik Mat might have overstayed his welcome.

Nik Aziz, 81, besides Sarawak Chief Minister Taib Mahmud, were the only holdover leaders from the 1990 general election.

Most of the PAS spiritual adviser's nemises such as former premier Dr Mahathir Mohamad have retired, although the latter tends to offer occasional input and advise to the present federal government.

Nepotism and factionalism

State Umno treasurer Hanafi Mamat confirmed this, saying there was some confidence that Umno could score a breakthrough but expressed caution as Barisan Nasional was often the underdog here.

He said this was because PAS had made a foothold on this east coast state since reclaiming it back in 1990.

If political observers study the nature of Kelantan politics, PAS had ruled the state longer than BN since 1957, he added.

But of late, Hanafi claimed, the momentum seemed to be shifting away from PAS, largely due to Nik Aziz overstaying.

It began to unravel after the hiring and eventual termination of his son-in-law Abdul Arifffahmi Abdul Rahman as CEO to a state subsidiary- the Kelantan Mentri Besar Incorporated Sdn Bhd.

The issue dragged on for weeks in 2009 and resulted in the PAS national leadership having to intervene after a blogger began to slowly expose alleged improper dealings of the state subsidiary.

For once, Hanafi said, the people here saw a level of nepotism in the state administration and then, Nik Aziz's son, Nik Abduh won the PAS Youth deputy chairman's post earlier this year.

"Spiritual empowerment is part and parcel of Kelantan voters. They want their leaders to be seen as holy and righteous. Once, they see another side, a tendancy for abuse or an unIslamic behaviour, they may stop supporting the incumbents. This is where PAS is worried," he said.

Hanafi claimed that the myth of piousness surrounding Nik Aziz had began to fracture and the spillover was evident in the state administration.

The state government had alleged factions, one led by state PAS deputy commissioner III Nik Amar Nik Abdullah and deputy mentri besar Ahmad Yakcop as well as state PAS strongman Takiyuddin Hassan. The other, or rather operating in isolation, was PAS vice-president and state economic czar Husam Musa, whom many in Umno believe, is the political god-son of Nik Aziz.

Factionialism impeded the state government from focusing on development and the state was more than ever, reliant on the repartition of income from outside of Kelantan to generate growth.

Basic utilities such as water and electric supplies were also lacking in large swatches of the hinterland here while the main economic indicators were mostly in the low-end jobs of logging, land transactions, agriculture and cross-border trade.

Another encouraging sign for Umno, was the two by-elections held since 2008.

In Manek Urai, PAS only won with a majority of less than 70 votes while in Galas last year, Umno regained the seat it lost in 2008, largely due to the influence of the long-serving Gua Musang MP Tengku Razaleigh Hamzah, Hanafi said.

Currently, Umno or BN held six out of the 45 seats in the legislative assembly.

Hanafi said another indication of support was the gravitation of the large state civil service corps towards Umno.

"I think the public sector is also getting fed up with the lack of movement on state policies. Furthermore, Nik Aziz is frail and at times, has to be hospitalised. This hampers the functions of the state machinery," he said.

After the 2008 general election, Kelantan PAS was expected to play a major role in the national political scene since Pakatan Rakyat was formed and it controlled Kedah, Penang, Perak and Selangor besides Kelantan.

READ MORE HERE

 

Analysts pour cold water on shadow budget

Posted: 04 Oct 2011 07:14 PM PDT

The budget is too focused on pleasing the civil servants instead of finding ways to expand the revenue base, they say.

Centre for Strategic Development chief executive officer Fui K Soong said Pakatan's budget should find ways of increasing the nation's revenue base instead of being too focused on expenditure. She said one way was for Pakatan to formulate policies that would promote growth in the private sector to increase the tax base that would eventually generate more income for the country.

G. Vinod, Free Malaysia Today

While lauding Pakatan Rakyat for announcing its shadow budget for 2012, several analysts said the budget failed to address many fundamental issues plaguing the nation's economy.

Yesterday, Opposition Leader Anwar Ibrahim announced its RM220 billion shadow budget, themed "Prosperity for All", which he said was aimed at overhauling the country's "flawed" macro and micro economic management.

Anwar also said that, among others, the Pakatan budget would look into assisting the poor by allocating RM22 billion in subsidies for basic goods and ensuring long-term fiscal survival which would focus on trimming the nation's deficit.

Calling it a populist budget, analyst Khoo Kay Peng said the budget was too focused on pleasing the civil servants at the expense of the nation's coffers.

While other countries such as Greece and Japan were trimming down their civil service, Khoo said Malaysia's political parties were more focused on increasing the civil servants' perks to fish for votes.

"I have no issue with increasing their salaries but we must remember that our civil service is over-bloated," said Khoo.

He added that to solve the problem, a massive structural reform was needed to reduce the dependence on foreign labour.

'Strong political will needed'

Khoo said the problem arose when the private sector, in a bid to reduce costs, hired foreigners to fill its vacancies at the expense of locals.

As a result, he said, the local skilled and unskilled workforce was deprived of jobs.

"And fearing a political backlash, the government absorbs these unemployed locals into the civil service," he said.

Khoo added that to solve the problem, both the government and private sector must come together to create jobs and ensure only locals are hired.

"But a strong political will is needed," he said.

Centre for Strategic Development chief executive officer Fui K Soong said Pakatan's budget should find ways of increasing the nation's revenue base instead of being too focused on expenditure.

She said one way was for Pakatan to formulate policies that would promote growth in the private sector to increase the tax base that would eventually generate more income for the country.

'Plucked out of thin air'

Praising Pakatan for introducing a minimum wage for civil servants, Fui reminded the opposition pact that the policy must be linked to an increase in productivity.

"We must remember that a minimum wage policy is a tool to prevent abuses by employers and to look after the workers' welfare; it is not a way to eradicate poverty," she said.

Soong also said that the shadow budget, while explaining expenditure, did not elaborate much on how much income is to be collected to foot the bill and the sources of revenue.

"It didn't address on how to expand our revenue base as well," she said.

READ MORE HERE

 

Noose Tightens in French Defense Scandal

Posted: 03 Oct 2011 09:13 PM PDT

Asian dimension as French state-owned arms company faces murder, bribery allegations

Breham said Razak Baginda's company Perimekar had received the commission for "supporting the contract," which he said was a euphemism for unexplained costs, and also for "housing the crew" of the submarines in France. Perimekar was wholly owned by another company, KS Ombak Laut Sdn Bhd, which in turn was also controlled by Razak Baginda. His wife Mazalinda, a lawyer and former magistrate, was the principal shareholder, according to the French lawyers. 

Written by John Berthelsen, Asia Sentinel

After years of inaction and coverup, details are emerging in France of the sale of armaments by the French state-owned defense contractor DCNS to countries across the world including Pakistan, Malaysia, Chile, India, Taiwan and Saudi Arabia, with bribes and kickbacks built into DCNS's budget, ensnaring politicians across the globe.

Allegations involving DCNS, formerly known as DCN, range from murder to bribery and corruption and go from defense procurement officials in each of those countries to some of the top politicians in France.

Under the French legal system, prosecutors under the control of the Ministry of Justice must make a preliminary enquiry, during which no one has access to the files, so that any information the police have obtained cannot be shared. The prosecutors have been stymied for years by the ministry. However, investigators appear to be losing their awe of politicians all the way up to President Nicholas Sarkozy.

In September, for instance, Nicholas Bazire, 54, the best man at Sarkozy's wedding to supermodel Carla Bruni, was arrested and charged with misuse of public funds in the 1995 presidential campaign of Edouard Balladur. Sarkozy was Balladur's campaign spokesman and budget minister at the time. Another friend, Thierry Gaubert, Sarkozy's cabinet chief when he was budget and communication minister, was arrested earlier. Sarkozy is seeking avoid the appointment of an instruction judge in an effort to keep the cases under control. But the political knives may be out for Sarkozy.

That increases the chances that investigating judges will allow prosecutors a more detailed look at DCNS's books to probe kickbacks in Pakistan, where 11 French submarine engineers were killed in a bomb attack, and Taiwan, where a number of murders and suicides have been recorded in connection with the sale of frigates to Taiwan's navy. The details can be found here.

William Bourdon, the leader of a three-lawyer team investigating Malaysia's US$1 billion purchase of submarines from DCNS for the Malaysian reform organization Suaram, earlier told Asia Sentinel he hoped his team would have access to the files by October. Bourdon was summarily deported from Malaysia in July after giving a speech in Penang describing some of the details of the allegations.

Prime Minister Najib Tun Razak was defense minister at a time when Malaysia bought two Scorpene-class submarines from DCNS. Included in the transaction was a €114 million commission paid to Perimekar Sdn Bhd, a company owned by Najib's close friend, Abdul Razak Baginda. The transaction has been mired in controversy since 2006, when Altantuya Shaariibuu, a party girl and translator ostensibly hired to help in the contract, was murdered after demanding US$500,000 from Razak Baginda, her jilted lover, for unspecified reasons. Razak Baginda was acquitted of her murder under unusual circumstances without having to provide a defense. Two of Najib's police bodyguards were convicted and sentenced to death. They have appealed the verdict.

Joseph Breham, a lawyer with Solicitors International Human Rights Group and a member of Bourdon's team, said in London last week that DCNS often budgeted as much as 8 to 12 percent of its total receipts as "commissions" paid to grease sales of armaments in third-world countries. Breham's speech was reported for the Malaysia website Malaysiakini by Miriam Mokhtar.

Malaysia bought two Scorpene submarines from DCNS for about US$1 billion and leased a third from a DCNS subsidiary for training. Of that, the €114 commission was paid to Razak Baginda's company, Perimekar Sdn Bhd.

Breham said Razak Baginda's company Perimekar had received the commission for "supporting the contract," which he said was a euphemism for unexplained costs, and also for "housing the crew" of the submarines in France. Perimekar was wholly owned by another company, KS Ombak Laut Sdn Bhd, which in turn was also controlled by Razak Baginda. His wife Mazalinda, a lawyer and former magistrate, was the principal shareholder, according to the French lawyers.

Breham questioned why such vast sums could be paid to Razak Baginda's company. The €114 million obtained by Ombak Laut, he said, was more than the amount paid by France to all of its primary school teachers for a year. He also revealed that DCNS's former finance director had written memos in which he alleged that €31 million of the €114 million had been used for "commercial engineering", a term Breham said had no legal meaning.

Breham said that in France, before 2002, any money used to bribe foreign officials was tax deductible. When the former finance director of DCN made a claim for the €31million allegedly used to bribe the Malaysians for the purchase of the Scorpenes, the Minister of Budget questioned such a large bribe, although he did eventually authorize the tax break.

READ MORE HERE

 

Alarm bells over unions’ bluster on RM1,500 base wage

Posted: 02 Oct 2011 04:06 PM PDT

The Malaysian Insider understands that the current civil service pay structure begins from a baseline of about RM500 a month, but with a new scheme set to be announced this month, this could rise to RM700. Shamsuddin said the average foreign worker now earned about RM750 per month and any rise would be pure disposable income that would be repatriated to their home countries.

The country's main labour centre's push for a RM1,500 per month base wage has raised the hackles of other stakeholders who warn that businesses will collapse while inflation spirals out of control with such minimum salaries.

Employers also said that as the four million foreign workers make up the bulk of those earning below that mark, their RM22 billion repatriated annually could double and far surpass last year's RM29 billion in foreign direct investment (FDI).

The Malaysian Trades Union Congress (MTUC) raised the bar last week from its previous demand of RM900 just as the National Wage Consultative Council (NWCC) held its first meeting to begin discussing a national minimum wage. Both public and private sector workers say wages need to go up to cope with inflationary pressures and rising prices of staple goods apart from fuel costs.

But others are wary of the distortionary effects of setting a high base wage, insisting instead that efforts should be focused on upgrading the glut of unskilled workers to fill the dearth of semi- and highly-skilled workers.

"This figure seems to be plucked out of thin air," Malaysian Employers Federation (MEF) executive director Shamsuddin Bardan told The Malaysian Insider.

Malaysia has always prided itself as a low-cost centre for manufacturing since the 1970s, offering tax incentives, cheap electricity, land and labour to entice multinationals to set up base. But prices are rising and the Najib administration has targeted 2020 for Malaysia to be a high-income nation.

Centre for Public Policy Studies director Ng Yeen Seen said that a minimum wage should be geared towards avoiding exploitation, rather than creating hard and fast ideals.

She said labour exploitation was particularly rife in Sabah and Sarawak, where some were paid as little as RM180 a month.

But paying cleaners, dishwashers and maids RM1,500 would wreak havoc on operating costs of most businesses as wage bills are usually kept under 20 per cent of total expenditure.

"The unions should ask themselves what will happen when most SMEs are forced out of business," said Ng, who is a member of the NWCC's technical committee.

The Malaysian Insider understands that the current civil service pay structure begins from a baseline of about RM500 a month, but with a new scheme set to be announced this month, this could rise to RM700.

Shamsuddin said the average foreign worker now earned about RM750 per month and any rise would be pure disposable income that would be repatriated to their home countries.

He pointed out that foreign labour already sent RM22 billion out of our economy last year and rising wages will likely to discourage foreign investors.

He said that Singapore already attracts far more FDI than Malaysia with RM114 billion against RM27 billion in 2008 and RM52 billion to RM4 billion in 2009.

But this was because the island's average productivity was 3.8 times Malaysia's while wages were only triple, making the republic "better in terms of cost per unit," he added.

READ MORE HERE

 

Kredit: www.malaysia-today.net

Malaysia Today - Your Source of Independent News

0 ulasan
Klik GAMBAR Dibawah Untuk Lebih Info
Sumber Asal Berita :-

Malaysia Today - Your Source of Independent News


Hudud row a boon for Najib, says WSJ

Posted: 05 Oct 2011 06:27 PM PDT

(The Malaysian Insider) - Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak should thank his political foes for resurrecting the hudud issue, according to the Wall Street Journal (WSJ) Online, which called it a timely boost to his sliding popularity as national polls loom.

"Malaysian leader Najib Razak's effort to reinvent himself as the country's 'coolest' prime minister is getting a bit of a lift from a row in the opposition over unfashionable Islamic hudud laws," the influential US daily said today.

It observed the DAP-PAS-PKR alliance was now tangled in regular debate over the enforcement of Islamic penal laws in mutireligious Malaysia, handing the ruling Barisan Nasional (BN) a much-needed edge to claw back support ahead of an expected early 13th general election.

The Chinese-majority DAP last week pledged that its leadership would resign en masse if hudud laws are implemented, after Islamist partner PAS's spiritual advisor Datuk Nik Aziz Nik Mat told reporters the party would seek to adopt the Islamic penal laws nationwide if it wins in the coming polls.

This forced Pakatan Rakyat (PR) head and PKR advisor Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim to mediate between the two and calm public opinion.

Anwar has said the opposition will not necessarily carry out hudud if it takes over Putrajaya.

"The net result of all this wrangling, political analysts say, is to do Mr Najib a favour at a time when he is trying to reclaim the centre-ground of Malaysian politics," WSJ writer James Hookway wrote in the article headlined, "Malaysia's Recurring Row Over Islamic laws Could Lift Najib".

"That left Mr Najib largely free to focus on preparing a budget speech due Friday (tomorrow) that many analysts expect to contain a series of cash giveaways, such as tax rebates, civil services bonuses and lower personal tax rates, in the run-up to national elections that must be held within the next 18 months," he added.

The prime minister is expected to roll out a populist Budget to combat the rising cost of living before calling for an early general election next year, ahead of the 2013 expiry of the BN mandate.

The global economy is forecast to turn gloomier, which could deal a death blow to the Najib administration if it chooses to see out its mandate to full term.

READ MORE HERE

 

Sodomy II: Najib, Rosmah need not testify

Posted: 05 Oct 2011 05:53 PM PDT

Anwar has failed to show the relevancy and materiality of both Najib and Rosmah to the trial, ruled the judge.

(Free Malaysia Today) - Opposition Leader Anwar Ibrahim has failed in his bid to haul up Prime Minister Najib Tun Razak and his wife Rosmah Mansor to court to testify in his Sodomy II trial.

Judge Mohamad Zabidin Mohd Diah today allowed an application by the couple to set aside the subpoenas compelling them to be defence witnesses in the trial.

"After going through the affidavits and submissions, I found that the defendants have failed to show the relevancy and materiality of both Najib and Rosmah to the trial," said Mohamed Zabidin.

Meanwhile, Anwar said he was disappointed with the court's ruling.

"Of course, I'm disappointed because both of them (Najib and Rosmah) were clearly involved. We have evidence to support that…

"Our position is that this was planned. Now he (Najib) should come and deny it," he said.

He added that the prosecution offered them as witnesses. "(So) if they are not relevant, why were they offered (as witnesses)?"

Anwar's lead counsel Karpal Singh said that the defence would appeal against the decision at the Court of Appeal tomorrow.

He said he was also disappointed that the judge did not give any reasons for the decision to set aside the subpoenas.

"He ought to have given the reasons," said Karpal.

'Fishing expedition'

On Monday, Mohamad Zabidin heard submissions from the couple's lawyers as well as from lawyers representing Anwar.

Anwar's argument is that it was important to have Najib and Rosmah to testify in his trial so that he could find out what had transpired in a meeting involving the prime minister and the complainant Mohd Saiful Bukhari Azlan.

Anwar also wants Rosmah to explain about her meeting with Muhamad Rahimi Osman, a close friend of Saiful. (Rahimi was said to have gone to Rosmah to seek assistance on behalf of his friend.)

READ MORE HERE

 

Ku Li says ‘Undilah’ video fit for viewing

Posted: 05 Oct 2011 05:11 PM PDT

By Shannon Teoh, The Malaysian Insider

KUALA LUMPUR, Oct 6 — Tengku Razaleigh Hamzah defended today his role in the controversial "Undilah" video, stating he was only trying to encourage the public to register to vote.

Despite critics stating that the public service announcement was anti-Barisan Nasional (BN), the Umno veteran gave it a thumbs-up when asked by reporters today in Parliament.

"Bagus (good). But if those with the power to ban it want to ban it, then go ahead," he said when asked his opinion of the clip before entering Parliament.

The Malaysian Insider reported that the Malaysian Communications and Multimedia Commission (MCMC) directed local broadcasters not to use the four-minute clip produced by musician Pete Teo just days after its launch on September 16.

But the MCMC insisted that the video was only taken off the air because it had not been approved by the Film Censorship Board.

Although Datuk Seri Najib Razak has insisted the video is not banned, Information, Communications and Culture Minister Datuk Seri Rais Yatim has said that the video is offensive and unsuitable for public consumption as it contains "subliminal messages".

Tengku Razaleigh said today that his segment, which opens the music video, was recorded independently of the rest of the clip and he was not aware who else would be featured in it.

"I was only asking people to register to vote. In fact, a lot of Malays have not registered," the Gua Musang MP said.

The video, which has been viewed over 500,000 times, also features rapper Wee Meng Chee, who has been accused of attacking Malaysia and being anti-Malay.

But Najib recently defended the musician, popularly known as Namewee, calling him a "strong supporter of 1 Malaysia."

READ MORE HERE

 

Snubbing China closes trade doors further, says Pakatan

Posted: 05 Oct 2011 04:44 PM PDT

By Shannon Teoh, The Malaysian Insider

KUALA LUMPUR, Oct 6 — The federal opposition has warned that Putrajaya's shifting position in proposed deals with China-based firms has further dented Malaysia's chances of spurring trade.

Pakatan Rakyat (PR) lawmakers noted that with economic giants Europe and the United States facing prolonged debt crises, Malaysia is sending the wrong signal to its fourth-largest trade partner.

"We can't afford to anger foreign investors, much less Chinese investors who we are aggressively wooing," said DAP publicity chief Tony Pua.

The Malaysian Insider reported yesterday that the Finance Ministry dropped mainland Chinese developer Everbright's US$1 billion (RM3.2 billion) redevelopment plan for Pudu Jail in favour of splitting the eight-hectare prime land into three parcels to be developed by mainly Bumiputera companies.

It also reported yesterday that Putrajaya has decided to forgo a cheap RM2.6 billion loan from China to build the Second Penang Bridge, and has instead asked state-owned Bank Pembangunan to further underwrite the construction of the 24km bridge which is now due in 2013.

The loan, which was seen as a sign of closer ties between Malaysia and its largest export market, was set with an interest loan of three per cent for 20 years, understood to be marginally lower than the Bank Pembangunan rate.

PAS research chief Dzulkefly Ahmad (picture) said "this raises questions about the kind of signal we are sending to what is probably the most important economy in the world while Europe and America struggle with double-dip recessions."

PKR secretary-general Saifuddin Nasution said these moves continue a trend of delays and flip-flops in business relations with China that "lowers confidence that Malaysia knows how to plan and stick to agreements."

 

READ MORE HERE.

Return IWK services to local councils, says Pua

Posted: 05 Oct 2011 04:32 PM PDT

By Clara Chooi, The Malaysian Insider

KUALA LUMPUR, Oct 6 — DAP MP Tony Pua today urged Putrajaya to return Indah Water Konsortium's (IWK) sewerage treatment and management business to the local councils, pointing out the centralisation of its services had resulted in a costly bailout for the government.

He, however, lauded the Finance Ministry's response in Parliament today that IWK would not be privatised but instead restructured and placed under the Energy, Green Technology and Water Ministry.

But, said the Petaling Jaya Utara MP, the government should "take a further step" by decentralising IWK's services, reminding that prior to 1994 local councils were in charge of sewerage treatment.

"The IWK was formed in 1997 as part of (former prime minister) Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad's privatisation initiative and took over all the relevant functions from the local government authorities.

"To ensure increased effectiveness and greater responsiveness to issues faced by the people, it is crucial that the local councils are empowered to manage its services," he said in a statement handed out in Parliament today.

Putrajaya said yesterday it had spent RM1.2 billion to sustain IWK since nationalising the national sewerage company in 2000.

The Finance Ministry said that IWK had racked up liabilities amounting to RM2 billion, while its assets are valued at about RM1.2 billion.

It also said that there are no plans to privatise IWK but the Energy, Green Technology and Water Ministry would be restructuring the sewerage industry, reviewing sewerage tariffs and guaranteeing future capital expenditure.

Second Finance Minister Datuk Seri Ahmad Husni Hanadzlah had said on September 10 that IWK would be merged with a government unit, confirming a report by The Malaysian Insider.

Ahmad Husni said that the merger process was already under way but declined to disclose the name of the government subsidiary, except to say that IWK would continue to be government-owned after the merger.

The Malaysian Insider reported on September 8 that IWK would be privatised into a consortium led by strategic investment agency 1MDB, some 11 years after the government was forced to bail out the national sewerage company from financial difficulties under its previous owners.

Finance Ministry sources had recently told The Malaysian Insider that the 1MDB-led consortium will include water distribution company Puncak Niaga, and that the deal has been given the nod by the Economic Council chaired by Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak.

Under the proposed deal, the 1MDB consortium was to acquire IWK for RM1 and take over its debts which include more than RM1.5 billion in loans still owed to the ministry.

The consortium is seeking a 60-year concession from the government and will only pay back the principal amount and interest on the loan over the long term.

 

READ MORE HERE.

Even if it weakens Pakatan, Nik Aziz wants hudud

Posted: 05 Oct 2011 04:28 PM PDT

By K Pragalath, FMT

PETALING JAYA: Kelantan Menteri Besar Nik Aziz Nik Mat remains adamant about implementing hudud in the state even if this resulted in Pakatan Rakyat becoming weakened.

"I went through the newspapers over the past few days and they are not playing up the hudud issue as vigorously as they did last week. I hope they would, even if it weakens Pakatan because more people would understand the truth about hudud.

"Perhaps the media realised that hudud cannot be used as Umno's tool as it would backfire," read the PAS spiritual adviser's posting on Facebook.

Controversy over hudud erupted last month when the PAS leader announced his intention to implement the Islamic law after former premier Dr Mahathir Mohamad dared Nik Aziz to implement it.

Nik Aziz also stressed that hudud would only affect the Muslims.

However, PAS' Pakatan coalition partner DAP had objected, saying the move would contradict the Federal Constitution.

Last week, Pakatan supremo Anwar Ibrahim anounced that hudud cannot be implemented due to lack of concensus among the coalition's component parties.

'Food more important than hudud'

In an immediate reaction, Perak DAP chief Ngeh Koo Ham said that Nik Aziz's view might weaken Pakatan.

"It would be better to raise other issues than hudud because it would reduce the votes that we get. Issues such as people-centric policies would be supported by all good human beings," he told FMT.

He cited good governance and transparency as among the issues that would garner support from all people.

He said under current times, "putting food (on the table) is more important than hudud".

 

READ MORE HERE.

Ex-MAS boss broke the law, says Nazri

Posted: 05 Oct 2011 04:26 PM PDT

By Syed Jaymal Zahiid, FMT

KUALA LUMPUR: Former MAS chairman Tajuddin Ramli breached the Companies Act in not disclosing his interests when he was with the national carrier, Minister in the Prime Minister's Department Nazri Aziz told the Dewan Rakyat today.

"Evidence shows that he breached Section 131 of the Companies Act, which involves disclosure of interests," he said in response to Lim Kit Siang (DAP-Ipoh Timur), who noted that there had been no prosecution against Tajuddin despite the reports MAS had lodged with the police and anti-graft authorities.

Lim asked if the Attorney-General had the right to absolve Tajuddin of criminal liabilities.

Nazri said Tajuddin had incurred a compound fine but the Attorney-General had delayed action on the fine because a civil suit had yet to be resolved.

"As the case involves a civil claim that has not been resolved, he asked the Attorney-General's Chambers to delay the compound. The AG's Chambers has granted the request."

In August, Putrajaya directed all government-linked companies (GLCs), including MAS, to drop all civil suits against Tajuddin.

 

READ MORE HERE.

Dr M backed move to acquire PKFZ land, Ling trial told

Posted: 05 Oct 2011 04:23 PM PDT

By Yow Hong Chieh, The Malaysian Insider

KUALA LUMPUR, Oct 6 — Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad signed off on a government report recommending Putrajaya acquire, and not buy, the financially non-viable Pulau Indah land for the Port Klang Authority (PKA), the High Court here heard today.

The October 23, 2002 report prepared by the Finance Ministry, headed by then-Prime Minister Dr Mahathir, pointed out the land had many encumbrances and caveats and suggested the government use the Land Acquisition Act instead.

Former Treasury deputy secretary-general Datuk Abdul Rahim Mokti, who helped prepare the report, said landowners Kuala Dimensi Sdn Bhd (KDSB) and Koperasi Pembangunan Pulau Lumut Bhd (KPPLB) had used the land as collateral for loans "many times".

He told Tun Dr Ling Liong Sik's cheating trial KDSB alone had mortgaged the land six times and owed banks some RM380 million.

Abdul Rahim, 61, also said Treasury secretary-general Tan Sri Shamsudin Hitam had also recommended that the land be acquired in a June 19, 2001 letter to his counterpart in the Transport Ministry as it was cheaper and easier option than buying it.

PKA had originally been instructed by the Finance Ministry to acquire the land before receiving the Cabinet's go-ahead to purchase it.

Former MCA president Dr Ling was charged in July last year with knowingly deceiving the Cabinet into approving the land purchase for the Port Klang Free Zone (PKFZ) transshipment megahub, which resulted in wrongful losses for the government.

The prosecution has argued that the additional interest of 7.5 per cent per annum, amounting to some RM720 million, had pushed PKA's land purchase from RM1.09 billion to RM1.88 billion for the port project.

 

READ MORE HERE.

Najib and Rosmah can skip trial, court rules

Posted: 05 Oct 2011 01:50 PM PDT

By Shazwan Mustafa Kamal, The Malaysian Insider

KUALA LUMPUR, Oct 6 — Datuk Seri Najib Razak and his wife need not testify in the Sodomy II trial, the High Court ruled today.

Judge Datuk Mohd Zabidin Mohd Diah said that Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim's lawyers had failed to prove "relevancy" in issuing a subpoena to the prime minister and Datin Seri Rosmah Mansor to testify in the trial.

Lawyers acting for Najib and Rosmah have argued that the duo are not relevant witnesses to Anwar's ongoing sodomy trial and that they would not be able to offer any material evidence to the court.

But Anwar's lawyers have argued otherwise, saying Najib's testimony could shed light on the disposition of the opposition leader's accuser in the days leading up to the alleged incident.

Defence counsel Karpal Singh asserted that as the prime minister had met Mohd Saiful Bukhari Azlan on the night of July 24 — two days before the latter accused Anwar of sodomising him — Najib's account of the meeting would "go a long way" in assisting the court.

MORE TO COME HERE.

RM23,000 in tear gas hurled at Bersih marchers

Posted: 05 Oct 2011 01:46 PM PDT

By Shannon Teoh, The Malaysian Insider

KUALA LUMPUR, Oct 6 — Some 226 tear gas canisters and 36 smoke grenades worth RM22,886 were used to disperse the tens of thousands who gathered on July 9 to support Bersih's call for free and fair elections.

The Home Ministry said, in a parliamentary reply to Lim Lip Eng (DAP-Segambut), that each "Tear Smoke Shell" cost RM79.76 while "Tear Some Grenades" were valued at RM135 each.

File photo of tear gas fired to disperse the thousands at the July 9 rally.
Opposition leaders have accused police of attempted murder during the rally, claiming that tear gas shells were aimed directly at demonstrators with intention to harm.

The ministry also said on Tuesday that police were found to have breached standard operating procedures when dealing with marchers who had converged at the Tung Shin Hospital.

The government had said earlier this week that more than RM2 million was spent deploying over 11,000 police officers to "handle" the outlawed rally by the electoral reform group.

The protest turned chaotic when the police fired tear gas and water cannons at thousands of demonstrators, resulting in scores injured and the death of ex-soldier Baharuddin Ahmad, 59.

The ministry also clarified today that the total number of arrests on July 9 was 1,509, 97 of whom were female.

 

READ MORE HERE.

GST ‘maybe after elections,’ says Nazri

Posted: 05 Oct 2011 01:44 PM PDT

By Shannon Teoh, The Malaysian Insider

KUALA LUMPUR, Oct 6 — The government said it will not yet table a law to introduce the controversial goods and services tax (GST) despite listing it in the today's parliamentary order of business.

Minister in the Prime Minister's Department Datuk Seri Nazri Aziz told The Malaysian Insider that the law will not be read today, saying only that its introduction "maybe even after elections, anything is possible."

"Yes, today we go back early," he said when asked if today's proceedings would stop before the GST Bill.

The implementation of GST was first mooted by Putrajaya in 2009 but public outcry due to rising cost of living has seen the government postponing its roll-out.

The proposed law states that it will be up to the finance minister to decide when GST will be implemented and at what rate.

"This Act comes into operation on a date to be appointed by the minister... and may appoint different dates for the coming into operation of different parts or different provisions of this act," the Bill reads.

"The minister may... fix the rate of tax to be charged on the supply of goods or services or on the importation of goods; and vary or amend the rate of tax fixed," it continues.

It further states that the tax shall be levied of any goods or service made in or imported into Malaysia.

The federal opposition tabled an alternative Budget earlier this week calling for a total of RM12.8 billion to be injected to raise income after seeing cost of living surge this year.

Pakatan Rakyat (PR) also said RM22 billion must be maintained for subsidies to avoid any rise in fuel prices and to keep inflation, which has persisted at a two-year high of over three per cent since March, under control.

Household debt has also climbed to 77 per cent of gross domestic product (GDP) at the end of last year, which PR says has more than doubled from 33 per cent in 1997.

 

READ MORE HERE.

Sex education, finally

Posted: 05 Oct 2011 10:32 AM PDT

By T.K. Letchumy Tamboo, The Malay Mail

AFTER a six-year delay, sex education is likely to be taught to Year Six and Form Three students next year as a pilot project in several schools in the country.

The decision to introduce social and reproductive health education (SRHE) into primary and secondary school classrooms came about from discussions between the Education Ministry and the Women, Family and Community Development Ministry.

Women, Family and Community Development Minister Datuk Seri Shahrizat Abdul Jalil told The Malay Mail it would be taught as a co-curricular subject after the Ujian Penilaian Sekolah Rendah (UPSR) and Penilaian Menengah Rendah (PMR) examinations.

"We have sent the proposal for the subject to be taught in schools to the Education Ministry and they have agreed, in principle, to study the implementation of teaching the subject in schools.

"Hopefully, it could be implemented next year after the UPSR and the PMR examinations.

"If everything goes well, the implementation of this subject will start as a pilot project first in several schools we have identified."

Sex education in schools was mooted in 2005 as a joint effort by both ministries and got the Cabinet's green light in December 2006.

It received a mixed reaction from various quarters despite its aims of educating the young to respect gender and sexuality, with the ultimate aim of reducing sexual crimes.

The latest developments arose from findings of the two ministries' pilot project, named 'I'm In Control', a sexual reproductive health module introduced to Form Four and Five students from five secondary schools in Kuala Lumpur, Selangor, Penang, Kelantan and Pahang.

It also went on trial at three kafe@TEEN centres, a one-stop service centre providing information and education related to adolescent reproductive health, counselling and medical treatment for reproductive health problems to adolescents, aged 13 to 24.

The module, being tested by the National Population and Family Development Board (NPFDB) from mid-2009 to the end of this year, includes pointers like assertive techniques to avoid premarital sex and how to identify and avoid high-risk situations.

Shahrizat said 308 students attended the workshops.

The pilot project continued last year with 14 more workshops at the same schools and kafe@TEEN centres, in which 597 students took part.

"Feedback from the participating students, teachers and parents was positive," she said.

Shahrizat said further discussions were held between both ministries between February and July to study ways in which SRHE could be introduced and implemented in schools at the national level.

She said the ministry was looking at using different avenues to reach out and make SRHE available to a wider audience through a larger project, called Upscaling Kafe@TEEN Programmes, which began in 2008 and expected to end next year.

"In line with this, 'I'm In Control' workshops have been conducted by selected non-governmental organisations and NPFDB trainers nationwide," she said.

This year, emphasis was given to train trainers on the parents' edition of the 'I'm In Control' module. Two training of trainers (TOT) sessions were held in August involving 88 NPFDB officers, followed by 10 dialogue sessions between parents and teachers until the year-end.

Evaluation of the project's overall effectiveness would be conducted during the final year, 2012.

Earlier this year, SRHE officially became a subject taught in the National Service Training Programme.

Govt concealing new oil profits from Kelantan

Posted: 05 Oct 2011 10:18 AM PDT

(Harakah Daily) - Oct 6: Having denied Kelantan its share of oil royalty for oil extracted from its territory, the Barisan Nasional government is now accused of hiding oil revenues from two oil fields.

Kelantan's State Petroleum Royalty Claims committee chairman Husam Musa said the state was not informed of oil and gas from 24 out of 32 oil fields in Bumi and Suria in Kelantan waters.

"Not only they keep denying the state oil royalty, in fact the state was not told of the latest revenue harvested.

"This is immoral because it amounts to robbing the state of its wealth," he said.

 

 

READ MORE HERE.

Najib's high-tempo pursuits bearing fruit

Posted: 05 Oct 2011 10:11 AM PDT

(NST) - IN a football match, games played in the English Premier League particularly, a recurring tactic of club managers is a high-tempo game -- one sparkling in attacking flair that the opposing side is impelled to defend with little chance to mount their own attacks.

You might want to adopt this football analogy to how politics is played out now. 

Politicians, depending on their positions or if they are top party or government leaders, are always looking for the high-tempo strategies to retain their mandate; galvanising members and supporters; nourishing constituents and producing seminal policies that propel the nation into major global diplomatic and socio-economic players.

One in four is always a good option if your resources are limited, but in Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak's case, he has opted for four out of four, such is the confidence he exudes in recent months.

Najib has emulated the high tempo football strategy in the 30 months since he took office; the tempo of his policies so ascending you'd wonder whether he is able to sustain such highs. Evidently he can. Repealing the tough security laws in the context of Malaysian politics is such a big deal that you'd think the prime minister would have used this stunning gambit as a political endgame to score big in the coming general election.

When Najib took office in April 2009, one of his big ticket policy shifts was repealing the Internal Security Act and other security laws that are relics of the Cold War.

Just when you thought the tempo was feverishly high, he revs it higher with the release yesterday of 125 people held under the Restricted Residence Act 1933 while countermanding police warrants that would have curbed the movements of 200 others. And this in is just the last two weeks.

Of course, in the 30 months since, there had been a series of fast and furious policy and project announcements -- economic liberalisation, exhilarating free speech, especially on race relations, promise of electoral reforms with the formation of the Parliamentary Select Committee and, on Friday, the 2012 Budget to mitigate the worries of the proletariat.

You'd ask: what is Najib's endgame, which people associate with positives for the 13th general election? Curiously, that endgame is nowhere in sight, at least not this year when clearly, Najib is unlikely to call for a snap general election despite the tempting indications he has cast.

You can ignore though the opposition's hoary quarterly predictions that polls are just around the corner in the hope that the prime minister will acquiesce to the tiresomely laughable polls exhortation parlour game. Many strongly feel the prime minister won't call the general election this year although the opposition is cavorting for snap polls purely on the idea that the big gains they were rewarded with on March 8, 2008 have steadily been sapped.

However, Najib, too, has pursued comprehensive endeavours not met squarely as populist gestures: not everyone has been warm to his efforts, including some people within his flanks. 

The response seemed to be mixed and volatile, but from the prime minister's standpoint, that's exactly the reaction he expects on the principle that you simply cannot please everyone but only the ones who urgently need your help.

On that principle alone, Najib is sticking to the big picture, pushing an unstoppable momentum that by now is geared towards the high tempo we are experiencing now.

In assessing the lay of the political land, the prime minister, from his advantageous perch with all those think tanks, agencies and intelligence at his disposal, can "see" everything, from socio-economic demands, problems and solutions, to people hawking political claptrap, landmines and opportunities.

This is Najib's great advantage. Of course, in pushing players forward to sustain that high tempo, the attack-minded team might leave their defence vulnerable to an unexpected counter-attack, one which could concede an unnecessary goal.

Putting on the "football club" manager's hat, Najib has realised this downside but that didn't stop him from shoving an emphatic 'No' to the hudud, demanded by Pas, although certain segments of the Malay/Muslim populace found it agreeable.

His indirectly genial engagement with bad boy rapper Namewee caused some discomfort in the Establishment who felt he was "pushing his luck", as what some bloggers implied.

Perhaps. But Najib believes strongly in positively engaging the alternative crowd with the wild ideas of nation building on the conviction that if he wants to get things done, some political and socio-economic risks are not only necessary but prudent.

Trying to do what's effective for the nation is hard, as Najib would have reconciled now, especially if you continuously get flak from supporters who can't see the big picture, what more the foes.

Even a critic in former prime minister Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad will appreciate that there are circumstances only a sitting prime minister knows and understands, that he can see what you can't see and has the ability to do the things that you can't fathom.


Kredit: www.malaysia-today.net

Malaysia Today - Your Source of Independent News

0 ulasan
Klik GAMBAR Dibawah Untuk Lebih Info
Sumber Asal Berita :-

Malaysia Today - Your Source of Independent News


At variance with the Constitution

Posted: 05 Oct 2011 10:25 AM PDT

By Shad Saleem Faruqi, The Star

The clear intention of the 1957 Constitution was to allocate penal powers to the Federal Government and to confer on the states residual powers over minor syariah offences.

WHENEVER a general election appears to be around the corner, some people find it politically profitable to stoke the embers of controversy about the need for an Islamic state and its accompanying requisite – hudud laws – ie, laws relating to crimes, punishments and rights and duties that are mentioned in the Holy Quran.

Such a season of polemic is with us again and a few observations are in order.

First, it is a fact that since the 80s, many Muslims have been aspiring to give centrality to the Syariah in our legal system.

While this religious quest is understandable, its realisation requires massive legal reconstruction of the basic legal edifice.

We must be open-eyed about these changes and must accomplish them in accordance with, and not in disregard of, the constitutional charter.

Second, respecting the sensitivities and rights of other religious communities and living in peace and harmony with them under a system of just, fair and compassionate governance is also an important requirement of the Syariah.

Example of other Muslim countries where the hudud has been enforced and how hudud's implementation has impacted on war, peace or social harmony needs to be thoroughly studied.

Third, most acts deemed criminal under the hudud are also prohibited under our penal laws.

Whether it is murder, rape, theft, robbery, unnatural sex or incest, the prohibitions of the Syariah are replicated in our law. Supporters of the hudud should note that the major difference is in the severity of punishments, the rules of evidence and of proof.

In some cases, Syariah penalties are less severe. For example, drug offences under the Syariah do not attract mandatory death sentences. The life of a murderer can be spared if the victim's family accepts blood money in compensation.

In Islamic jurisprudence, the law of evidence, the right of the accused to retract a confession and the inadmissibility of the evidence of an agent provocateur grant better protection to the accused than under ordinary law.

On the other side, the severe Syariah punishments of severing of limbs and stoning to death are practised neither in our legal system nor in the vast majority of Muslim-majority nations.

Fourth, the religious and political debate about the hudud in this country seems to be proceeding in blissful disregard of the constitutional scheme of things.

Actually, the Federal Constitution has provided clear guidance about who may legislate for crimes, who may prosecute criminal offences, which courts may try offenders, who is the subject of the law and what penalties may be imposed.

The Constitution is supreme and its imperatives cannot be lightly disregarded.

Who may legislate crimes?

In Schedule 9 List I Paragraph 4, criminal law and procedure, the administration of justice, official secrets, corrupt practices, creation of offences in respect of any of the matters included in the federal list or dealt with by federal law are in the hands of Parliament.

Under Schedule 9, List II, Para 1 the states have a power to create and punish Islamic offences subject to a number of significant limitations.

First, State legislative authority in respect of "creation and punishment of offences by persons professing the religion of Islam against precepts of that religion" is limited by the words "except in regard to matters included in the Federal List". Among matters included in the federal list are civil and criminal law and procedure.

Second, State authority to legislate on Islamic crimes is further qualified by the words "or dealt with by federal law" in Schedule 9 List I Paragraph 4(h).

Betting and lotteries, murder, theft, robbery, rape, incest and unnatural sex are all offences in Islamic law but they are clearly in federal hands because of Schedule 9 List I Item 4(l) and 4(h) and the federal Penal Code.

The clear intention of the 1957 Constitution was to allocate almost all penal powers to the federation and to confer on the states only residual powers over Syariah offences like khalwat, zina, skipping of Friday prayers and failure to observe the compulsory fasts during Ramadan.

Who may be tried before Syariah Courts?

Under Schedule 9 List II Paragraph 1, Syariah Courts are permitted to exercise jurisdiction only over persons professing the religion of Islam.

A non-Muslim cannot be subjected to the Syariah or compelled to appear before the Syariah Courts. Even if he consents, the Syariah Court has no jurisdiction over him because jurisdiction is a matter of law, not of consent or acquiescence.

If my understanding is correct, in an Islamic state, Islamic criminal laws including hudud apply to all citizens. That would pose a great challenge to our existing constitutional jurisprudence and our provisions on freedom of religion.

Is Islam in the State List? Islamic law covers the whole range of civil, criminal, personal and commercial matters.

Islamic law encompasses environmental and international matters. A popular legal myth in Malaysia is that all Islamic matters are within state jurisdiction!

If this were so, then why the explicit limitations on the penal powers of the State Assemblies?

Why the need for detailed exposition in Schedule 9, List II Para 1 (the State List) of family and personal law matters? Why not just have the generic words "All matters covered by the Syariah" in the State List?

If all matters of Islam are in State hands, as some experts are arguing, then whether it is crime, tort, contract, banking, or commercial law, if it involves Muslims, the matter should be in State Assembly hands and triable by the Syariah Courts.

Malaysia would then become "one country, with two systems" – one for Muslims and the other for non-Muslims. This is not what the forefathers envisioned.

To underline the point that in the original scheme of things, Islamic law was shared between federal and state jurisdictions and not everything connected with Islam is in the hands of State Assemblies, one can note Paragraph 4(k) of the Federal List which specifically mentions that "ascertainment of Islamic law and other personal laws for purposes of federal law" are in federal hands.

What punishments may be imposed?

Schedule 9 List II Paragraph 1 states that Syariah Courts "shall not have jurisdiction in respect of offences except in so far as conferred by federal law".

The relevant federal law is the Syariah Courts (Criminal Jurisdiction) Act 1965. It confines Syariah Court jurisdiction to such offences as are punishable with maximum three years' jail, RM5,000 fine and six lashes. Any state law, including a hudud law, imposing larger penalties would be ultra vires the Act of 1965 and unconstitutional.

In sum, attempts by some States to legislate hudud laws and to impose hudud penalties will bring forth embarrassing constitutional law issues pitting the Constitution against religion.

Two prominent arguments in favour of the implementation of hudud need to be scrutinised.

First, the assertion that application of hudud in Malaya is not new because the Syariah was applied in Malaya in pre-British days.

With all due respect, "syariah" and "hudud" are not interchangeable.

In Malay history, there is centuries of tradition of Muslim personal law but I have difficulty documenting widespread application of hudud in Malaya.

Likewise the assertion is not convincing that because of the vox populi in some parts of the country, we must accept the change.

The Constitution cannot be overthrown by disputed historical assertions or by popular opinion.

Its procedures for amendments are elaborate and must be invoked.

Law must grow and change in accordance with the law and not by the opinion of the people or of self-anointed elites.

> Shad Faruqi is Emeritus Professor of law at UiTM and Visiting Professor at USM.

 

Right to question hudud law

Posted: 05 Oct 2011 10:24 AM PDT

By Azmi Sharom, The Star

My problem with religion-based law making, is the idea that it cannot be questioned because it is divine in origin. In a democracy, if we can't question the laws that affect our lives, then it is not a democracy at all.

POOR Fulham. Despite thoroughly thrashing Tony Fernandes' Queens Park Rangers 6-0, all the sports headlines were about the other London derby where Tottenham Hotspur edged Arsenal 2-1. I suppose it is all about perception; just what is important and what is not.

As much as I would like to think that the game at White Hart Lane is an indication that the power in North London has shifted to Seven Sisters road, I am ever cautious and am reminded of the saying that a swallow does not a summer make.

Although I suppose in the case of the Spurs-Arsenal rivalry, considering that we have beaten them three times in the last four league clashes, it just may be there is more than one swallow fluttering about.

However, I digress. My earlier point remains and that is the perception of what is important and what is not.

At the moment, there are all sorts of news stories floating about and they point towards one thing, elections.

PAS has once again raised the hudud issue. Frankly, I am not too worried about this matter.

Pakatan Rakyat has stated that they will not go on with hudud unless all the component parties agree.

This seems highly unlikely as DAP will never agree and I am sure there are some voices in Keadilan too who will not be comfortable with hudud.

However, if they do try to introduce it, I will most certainly object.

The reason why I object is encapsulated in Hadi's (PAS president Datuk Seri Abdul Hadi Awang) statement in the press on the matter (if it was accurately reported) where he said that hudud cannot be questioned.

Whoa there, "cannot be questioned"? I am sorry, if you have personal beliefs that affect only you and you won't question them, that's all fine and dandy.

But if you are going to introduce something into the public sphere, something that will affect the lives of the citizens, I don't care if the source of what you are introducing is divine, it jolly well better be questioned.

And I don't care if you say I have no degree from Al-Azhar and no goatee to go along with it, I will question any law that any government wants to introduce.

This has been my problem with any religion-based law making, the idea that simply because it is divine in origin means it can't be questioned. In a democracy, if we can't question the laws that affect our lives, then it is not a democracy at all.

And then there is poor Mat Sabu; charged with criminal defamation for questioning the heroism of the policemen who fought at Bukit Kepong.

I checked the Penal Code and sure enough, criminal defamation can be committed against the dead.

It's a bit weird because how far back does this provision extend? I mean in historical matters there will always be different perspectives and differing opinions based on new findings and discoveries.

In case the Government decides to charge me with criminal defamation for questioning the character of one of our early leaders, let me use an American example.

Thomas Jefferson; renaissance man who helped draft the American Constitution and ensured a modern democracy where all men were created equal, or a shameless hypocrite slave owner who fathered numerous children with his female slaves?

Both views are correct and depending on your own take on history the view that will take precedence will differ.

And surely that was what Mat Sabu's statement was; his take on history.

Was it insensitive, probably, should he be prosecuted for it, I don't think so.

However, all these issues are really not that important to me. I think they are just the usual sound and fury that come with politicians posturing in the light that elections are coming.

The real important story for now should be the Budget and more importantly the alternative budget that the Pakatan has unveiled.

It is really good to see Pakatan acting like they have a Shadow Cabinet (although they don't have one really).

We need to see concrete counter proposals from the opposition to not only help us question the Government's Budget but also to assess the alternatives which a different government could give. This is vital in a mature democracy.

I certainly hope that discussions in the next couple of weeks will be about comparing the two budgets for surely that is more important than a hudud law which is unlikely to be implemented and Mat Sabu's supposed lack of patriotism.

 

Kredit: www.malaysia-today.net
 

Malaysia Today Online

Copyright 2010 All Rights Reserved