Malaysia Today - Your Source of Independent News
Malaysia Today - Your Source of Independent News |
| Posted: 24 Nov 2012 02:51 PM PST
The policies of PAS in Kelantan have put its Pakatan Rakyat allies in an awkward spot. For the DAP, the value of hanging on to PAS is not in winning new seats but having a partner who can provide the Prime Minister or Mentri Besar if they win big, as was the case in Perak before the defection. Baradan Kuppusamy, The Star THERE is more to the hair controversy in PAS-ruled Kota Baru than meets the eye. For one, the woes of doing business have just multiplied and it also tells of the unfriendly business environment in Kelantan, which prides itself in allowing pig farms but not a woman cutting a man's hair and in full and open view. It also shows, especially to the business-oriented Chinese community, that supporting the Islamist party, no matter what the DAP does to justify and whitewash it ahead of the coming general election, is a step backwards. PAS is set to be dominant in Pakatan Rakyat and the intolerant rules it is imposing in Kelantan will eventually be translated into national policies by its representatives. Remember the protest against cinemas in Bangi and the gender segregation seating in cinemas in Sabak Bernam? Once the genie is out of the bottle it is impossible to wish it back in. By all counts, DAP is resurgent and while it is on course for a big victory at the polls, it is also urging Chinese voters to back its partner PAS. But no matter how liberal PAS pretends to be, it stumbles ever so often. It shows its inherent intolerance and narrow mindedness, all in the name of Islam, an intolerance that appears intrinsic to all religious parties. If PAS becomes dominant, which is within reach with its one million card-carrying members, and with DAP and PKR giving it added clout, what is to stop it from implementing the same policies nationwide? At stake is our liberal way of life. Salon operators in Kota Baru have been repeatedly summoned for allowing females to cut the hair of males or vice-versa, a prohibition imposed by the Kota Baru Municipal Council that is filled with PAS members. Gender segregation is openly enforced in Kelantan, and PAS says this is in accordance with Islam. But this is the first time where a non-Muslim female hairdresser has been summoned for cutting the hair of a non-Muslim male, a common enough practice everywhere else in the world except in Kelantan now. Islamic rules were only for Muslims but now that rule has clearly encroached into non-Muslim space, and such space is narrowing and likely to get worse with PAS on a dominant path. Can the DAP, which defends all things PAS and even goes about uttering Islamic verses, explain this intolerant tendencies? The same PAS party is in the news for praying for God's help to run down Umno and Barisan Nasional, wanting their destruction allegedly for being hard on Muslims. Thus far the DAP as well as PKR are silent on this prayer asking for the destruction of Umno/Barisan Nasional, a desperate attempt to energise rural Malay support that is slipping from under PAS. In the past, this very party had called Umno infidels, pig farmers and pharaohs, and told all who want to hear that Umno members won't go to heaven when they die. This is the party that is partnering with DAP and PKR and wants to get to Putrajaya in a big way. It shows a temporary liberal face that becomes unhinged ever so often, leaving red faces in the liberal PKR and secular DAP. A religious party advocating a theocracy simply has no role in a modern democracy, and a secular party like the DAP should have been aware of the limitations of a religious party before entering into a partnership. Despite the ever so often hiccups from PAS, the DAP has been advancing the political interest of PAS and in return gets the support of PAS Malay members in the urban centres the DAP will contest. But this support would only enlarge its majority in the urban centres, not win for it new seats. For the DAP, the value of hanging on to PAS is not in winning new seats but having a partner who can provide the Prime Minister or Mentri Besar if they win big, as was the case in Perak before the defection. Pure political expediency is at work here between DAP and PAS. Each gains something out of their alliance PAS gets Chinese voter support and wins in many marginal seats against traditional rival Umno, and DAP gets a Malay partner in government. As the hair cutting controversy unravels, the woes of the Chinese business community continue to multiply in Kelantan. One salon manager was summoned 11 times, the latest on Tuesday, another was issued with 10 summonses, and a third with four. It's a wonder the salons are in business at all. "I would understand it if we were fined for allowing our women workers to cut the hair of Muslim men. But they were attending to non-Muslim men," said a salon manager remonstrating against the rule. What will be next on the PAS list of don'ts ... female doctors for females only?
|
| Posted: 24 Nov 2012 02:40 PM PST
We should be on guard against politicians who try to pass themselves off as theologians, regardless of their religion. Wong Chun Wai, The Star IT'S incredibly silly and nave to actually believe that the religious push by PAS, especially the implementation of hudud and syariah laws, will not affect non-Muslims. There are many Chinese voters, swayed by anti-establishment sentiments towards Barisan Nasional, who have been easily convinced that the Islamist party is perfectly acceptable and that hudud laws would not encroach into the lifestyle of non-Muslims. So they take a light, if not cynical, response towards the call by the Chinese-based component parties in the Barisan and have dismissed the red flag raised by the MCA and Gerakan as no more than a scare tactic. Last week's report that a female Chinese hairstylist has been fined regularly by the Kota Baru Municipal Council for cutting the hair of male Chinese customers has revealed how the PAS agenda is affecting non-Muslims. Salon operators have learnt the hard way that gender segregation regulations in the PAS-controlled state apply to non-Muslims as well. The KB municipal council by-laws forbid women from cutting men's hair and vice-versa regardless of their religion. E-Life Hair Salon manager Ong Lee Ting said she has been paying fines of between RM200 and RM350, adding that she was warned the licence for the salon would be revoked because of the many summonses issued to the operator. While many of us may be used to the way the PAS state government has been running Kelantan with its strict religious regulations, including gender segregation at concerts and supermarket check-outs, some might not be aware that the party's leaders in other states have been doing something similar. In Bangi, Selangor, the PAS state assemblyman Dr Shafie Abu Bakar has stood firm against any proposal to set up a cinema in his constituency. A Chinese businessman reportedly tried to set up a cinema in Bangi but the PAS politician was the biggest stumbling block. When the issue was reported in February, Dr Shafie questioned the need for a cinema in his constituency when one could watch movies on television and the Internet. He claimed that his constituency was 97% Muslims who preferred to attend religious and educational classes. In July, PAS in Kuala Selangor insisted on putting up notices in a cinema forbidding unmarried couples from sitting together. State PAS Commissioner Dr Rani Osman said the directive was made by the licensing department of the Kuala Selangor district council. The state deputy commissioner Khalid Samad, who is purportedly a liberal, was reported as saying that the cinema was frequented by families and they had complained of couples making out there. He also reportedly described it as a poor man's nightclub! In Kota Baru, the PAS state government at one time reportedly insisted that the lights in cinemas must be switched on during the movie to prevent patrons from conducting immoral activities. In 1995, when PAS came to power in Terengganu, the first thing the state's then Mentri Besar Hadi Awang did was to demolish the replica of a turtle at a roundabout in Kuala Terengganu, saying it was akin to idol worshipping. This is the same man who has indicated his interest to be Prime Minister of Malaysia. But we must accept the fact that PAS politicians have always been very clear on what they want to achieve if they are in power. They have consistently and clearly made it known that implementation of hudud laws are on top of their agenda. It is only the apologists outside PAS that have tried to reassure their non-Muslim supporters that this would not happen or that hudud laws, even if implemented, would not affect non-Muslims. Try telling that to a non-Muslim rape victim if the perpetrators are Muslims. We should be on guard against politicians who try to pass themselves off as theologians, regardless of their religion. Those who challenged the authority of such politiciantheologians have found themselves being reminded that dissent means challenging God's laws. They are also put down by such figures who dismiss their critics as unqualified and incapable of carrying out a debate because the challengers are not religiously qualified. Suddenly, religion has become the monopoly of these political-religious characters. Malaysia is veering towards a dangerous situation where there are many non-Muslim voters who are prepared to vote in orthodox PAS leaders. They don't realise that they would be turning the clock back with their political adventurism. It could be a hair-raising experience!
|
| You are subscribed to email updates from Malaysia Today - Your Source of Independent News To stop receiving these emails, you may unsubscribe now. | Email delivery powered by Google |
| Google Inc., 20 West Kinzie, Chicago IL USA 60610 | |
0 ulasan:
Catat Ulasan